Beginning in Vienna: “Systems Are Brought Forth, Not Found”

This month I began a nine-month Senior Fellowship at the Vienna Centre for Advanced Studies (ViCAS), the University of Vienna’s new international interdisciplinary centre. I am delighted to be part of its inaugural cohort. Vienna feels like the right place to be doing this kind of thinking. Heinz von Foerster was born here in 1911, and the University’s Institut für Zeitgeschichte holds the Heinz von Foerster Archive, the Gordon Pask Archive, and the estate of Ranulph Glanville, gathered under the banner of the “Archives of Complexity.” Whilst this may be a misnomer, I want to use three posts to set out the thread I have been following in my own work, and to say why this city is a fitting place to take it up. As an aside I would see the archive as highly significant in the annals of second-order cybernetics and as such part of a much wider field of cyber-systemic scholarship. My ambition can be understood as a retelling and expansion of the ‘second-order’ cybersystemic narrative such that it may trigger changes in readers’ traditions of understanding and offer antidotes for escaping our current human-biosphere trajectory.

I begin with a word I now handle carefully: **system**. I urge you to do the same.

Von Foerster gave second-order cybernetics its name: the cybernetics of observing, not only of observed, things. He argued that objectivity is the delusion that observations could be made without an observer. The stable “objects” and “selves” we perceive are not simply given. They are what remains invariant when an observer operates recursively on its own results, which he called eigenforms. Self-reference stops being a paradox to be avoided and becomes the way stability is made.

Humberto Maturana reached the same place through biology. To call something a unity, or a system, is an act performed by an observer through an operation of distinction. Living organization, autopoiesis, is self-producing, but what we call “a living system” is what that distinction reveals. His corollary matters enormously for practice: an organism and its medium become structurally coupled through a history of mutual perturbation, yet nothing “instructs” anything. You can perturb another being. You cannot program it.

Gordon Pask turned this into a theory of conversation. Understanding is not a message travelling from sender to receiver. It is two actors, people, machines, or two perspectives within one mind, building agreement over understanding through rounds of question, answer, and demonstration. His early conversations with scholars in the Institute of Educational Technology at the Open University influenced how learning was to be framed.  Ranulph Glanville carried the idea into design: a designer converses with their own sketches and models, and any object is a black box stabilised through repeated interaction.

Peter Checkland, who died in May, never called himself a second-order cybernetician, yet Soft Systems Methodology makes the same move from organisational practice. “System” is a device of the inquiring mind, not a label for a slice of reality. His rich pictures, the CATWOE mnemonic, and his insistence on making each “Weltanschauung” explicit all serve a debate about change that is systemically desirable and culturally feasible. The point is learning, not verdicts.

Two conventions follow, and I will keep to them in these posts. First, I speak of a “situation of interest” before I speak of a system. A river catchment, a health service, or “the economy” is a situation that can be rendered systemic in several legitimate ways. A key issue becomes how and by whom situated issues or concerns become framed. Three questions follow: does deframing of the situation need to happen?  How might it be reframed? Can we gain insights and strategies for change if we engaging in a process of framing a situation of concern as if it were a system? As observers we bring forth systems by making boundary judgements, and the boundary is a choice we should own. Second, I avoid the word “goal” except when criticising it. Checkland deliberately built his models around “purposeful activity”. A goal implies a single end-state, fixed and agreed in advance. Real situations carry several partly reconcilable purposes, held differently by different people, and they shift as we learn. In the next post I explain what treating them otherwise has cost us.

Related Posts

Leave a Reply