My later work has turned the central question away from “what is the system?” and toward something more uncomfortable: what am I doing, moment to moment, when I act as a practitioner, and what does that say about being human? I frame this as “systems praxeology”, a disciplined practice of theory-informed action. Five ideas carry much of it.
“Duality, not dualism.” Checkland distinguished hard and soft systems thinking. In teaching mature students I saw that this hardened into a ranking: hard is rigorous, soft is fuzzy. Following a distinction made by Checkland early in his academic career, but a distinction he did not pursue, I reframed the pair hard/soft as “systematic” (procedural, step by step) and “systemic” (contextual, relational, boundary-aware). The crucial move is to hold them as a duality rather than a dualism. A dualism is a self-negating either/or. A duality, like predator and prey, only functions as a whole, and the systemic supplies the wider context in which systematic method can be judged. The lesson generalises. Treating “the social” and “the biophysical” as a dualism is what lets us speak of “the environment” as somewhere else.
“Metaphor and isophor.” A metaphor can enable creativity and change through evoking categorical differences in the same situation. An isophor is structurally alike to what is enacted as practice but involves a shift from one domain to another domain, so it works as both framework and method. My juggler isophor¹ pictures practice as keeping several things moving together: the practitioner’s Being, Engaging, Contextualsing and Managing (BECM) in situated and embodied practice. Every metaphor and isophor reveals some features and conceals others, and my work with several colleagues shows how water-governance metaphors quietly shape what seems possible.
“Enthusiasm and scenarioing” With David Russell I wrote about enthusiasm in second-order research and development, in work with graziers in western New South Wales. The word’s Greek root points to being animated from within. Change is taken up and sustained when people are engaged, not merely informed. With Andrea Grant and Richard Bawden I treated scenario work as a practice, scenarioing, rather than a product: a way of institutionalising knowing under uncertainty, and a counterweight to purely evidence-based forecasting.
“The knowing and knowledge duality” Taking a second-order understanding gives primacy to knowing (a practice) over knowledge (a reification of knowing). All knowing is doing. All doing is knowing, said Maturana. As Noam Cook and Henk Wagenaar write²: ‘knowledge and context can be explained in terms of—and are evoked within—practice, and not the other way round—and …this transpires within real worlds each of which has its own unique constraints and affordances, histories and futures.’ My work with the design and conduct of systemic inquiry, or co-inquiry and ‘learning systems’ are contributions to the praxis of systemic knowing and governing.
Together these suggest the capabilities a second-order cybersystemic praxeology needs today. I count eight but there are undoubtedly more:
– Boundary reflexivity, seeing that the boundary of a system of interest in a situation of concern is mine to draw and redraw.
– Multi-perspectival holding, working with incommensurable worldviews avoiding consensus and seeking ‘news of difference’ as Bateson has said.
– Purpose-creating and holding rather than goal-fixing, which in practice means resisting projectification e.g. through systemic inquiry.
– Designing learning systems for situational transformation rather than one-off projects.
– Structural rather than instructive intervention: shaping conditions, not issuing instructions e.g. managing or governing for emergence.
– Institutional literacy, reading rules as redesignable social technologies.
– Metaphor, isophor, and duality praxis literacy and capability.
– Tolerance for undecidability, joined to noticing what I am actually doing as I act.
Why has none of this gone mainstream? I see several reasons. It relativises the expert’s vantage point, on which professional legitimacy leans. It resists the metrics that audit cultures reward. It needs slowly built capability rather than a workshop. The tradition grew in small, dispersed centres rather than large departments. Its own reflexivity resists settling into a tidy canon, so ideas get rebranded without their roots. Projectification is itself an entrenched institution, and the bodies that would have to change are the ones asked to judge the change. And relational thinking challenges property regimes and command assumptions built on separating humans from nature.
None of that makes me pessimistic. It tells me where the work lies: noticing my own framings, building learning systems that outlast their funding, and redesigning institutions never designed for the situations we now face. Over these nine months in Vienna, I would welcome conversations with colleagues across the University and beyond who are wrestling with any of this.
- See Ison (2017) Systems Practice: How to Act. Springer & The Open University
- Cook SDN, Wagenaar H. Navigating the eternally unfolding present: Toward an epistemology of practice. American Review of Public Administration. 2012 Jan;42 (1):3-38. doi: 10.1177/0275074011407404
