What does it take for a plan for a river system to actually work over time?
That is the question at the centre of Professor Ray Ison’s submission to the 2026 Murray–Darling Basin Plan Review, which we’re pleased to make available for download here on Systemic Musings.
Ray is Emeritus Professor of Systems at The Open University (UK) and a Visiting Professor at UTS. He has spent more than two decades working on Basin governance as both researcher and practitioner. That work includes action research commissioned by the Murray-Darling Basin Authority in 2009 and evidence to the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Regional Australia in 2011. His submission draws on that body of peer-reviewed work, and on comparative studies from Australia, South Africa, Brazil, China and France.
The gap in the Discussion Paper
Ray’s starting observation is that the MDBA’s Discussion Paper covers a lot of substantive ground, but doesn’t name governance and governing as an explicit theme. He argues this is a persistent pattern in Basin reform since 2007, and one that has contributed to the very difficulties the Review is now trying to resolve.
Two distinctions that run through the paper
Governance versus governing. Governance is the structure: Acts, authorities, plans and limits. Governing is the ongoing process of steering a viable course in response to feedback. The Basin Plan has invested heavily in the first and far less in the second.
Systematic versus systemic. Systematic practice is linear, sequential and target-driven: checklists, compliance regimes and measurement. Systemic practice is relational and dynamic, attending to feedback, emergence and the interactions between parts. The Basin’s challenges (a changing climate, contested values, jurisdictional complexity) are systemic in character. Ray argues that meeting them requires systemic capabilities, not just better systematic ones.
What the submission covers
Organised around the Discussion Paper’s own chapter structure, the submission makes ten recommendations across five areas:
- Path dependency, drawing on Goulburn-Broken and the Northern Victoria Irrigation Renewal Project to show how centralised, technocratic framing keeps reasserting itself.
- Social learning, and why it needs a permanent, funded institutional home, with a comparison between the Crocodile and Olifants catchments in South Africa.
- Participation and legitimacy, including First Nations water rights and the role of Traditional Owners as custodians rather than stakeholders.
- Climate adaptation, and what governance looks like when “stationarity is dead”.
- Regulatory design, reconceived as the design of a governing system rather than a set of rules to be enforced.
A note on how submissions are read
The submission also speaks directly to how it should be read. With submissions potentially processed using generative AI for thematic grouping, Ray cautions against folding governance concerns into a generic “process” category weighed against “substantive” issues like allocation and environmental flows. His argument is that the quality of governing is the primary determinant of whether any substantive outcome can be achieved and sustained.
Read the submission
The full document, including the ten recommendations, a summary table and a selected bibliography, is available to download below. If you work in water, natural resource management, public policy or systems practice, we’d welcome your thoughts.
Ray has also offered to meet with the MDBA, the review team and the Minister, and to facilitate workshops or inquiry processes based on the approaches described in the paper.
